All for Hungary

Project Overview

A documentary about Hungarian university students who support the country’s far right Jobbik party.

Identifying the Problem

Part Hungarian, and having spent much of her childhood in Hungary, Swaan followed the political developments in Hungary for several years as a university student in the Netherlands. When the far right Jobbik party became the third largest party in the country, the general trend in the international media was to characterize supporters of far right parties as uneducated men who were angry and frustrated. Swaan was surprised to learn that a significant number of university students, especially those studying history/humanities, had voted for the Jobbik party in Hungary. From her university studies in the Netherlands, Swaan knew that the Dutch far right Freedom Party was not very popular among Dutch university students. She wanted to know what attracted Hungarian youth to a nationalist party with radical ideas about minority groups, especially Jews and Roma.

Swaan wrote her university thesis about educated Hungarian youth identifying with the far right. She submitted her completed thesis to Folia Magazine, the University of Amsterdam’s weekly publication, to see if the magazine would be interested in writing an article about the topic. Instead, Folia told Swaan that it had just begun experimenting with video material, and asked if she would be interested in working with journalist/editor Luuk Heezen to make a documentary about the topic. Swaan agreed, and she and Luuk set off to Hungary together.

Creating A Solution

The primary subjects of All for Hungary are university students in Hungary (attending university in Budapest and Miskolc) who support the Jobbik party. Swaan and Luuk identified these individuals and spoke with them about their personal stories, motivations, fears and hopes. It was very important to Swaan that she remain as neutral as possible during these interviews, as she wanted to ensure that her documentary presented an accurate and unbiased representation of those who identified with Jobbik. She often interviewed the students in places where they felt safe and comfortable, in order to elicit honest and uncensored answers and explanations from them.

Swaan and Luuk also attended the annual parade that marks the 1956 Hungarian revolt against the Soviet Union, which is regularly attended by Jobbik supporters. This event provided yet another opportunity to speak with these individuals and learn more about why they supported the far right party, and how they believed the party platform provided the best option for moving Hungary forward as a country.

Since much of the Jobbik party’s platform centers around radical views about the Roma, a minority ethnic group in Hungary that is often discriminated against, Swaan and Luuk decided to go to a Roma neighborhood to speak with some of its inhabitants. This portion of the documentary served to address the opinions that some Jobbik supporters had about the Roma community, as well as provide members of this community the opportunity to share their perspective on their position within Hungarian society.

The full documentary is available on YouTube.

Lessons Learned

Swaan emphasizes that preparation is the key to making a documentary that involves interviews. It is very important to plan on how you will approach your subjects, how you will present your project and how you will describe the nature and purpose of the interview. “People are not used to a camera, and if they don’t trust you, they won’t give you their story,” she says. The interviewer and the person filming the interview should both understand the steps that they will take in order to earn the subject’s trust and maintain a professional and comfortable environment during the interview. 

Swaan also realized that it is easy to imagine you project being so much larger than practicable, and that it is crucial to find the balance between creating an end product that is appropriate for a broader audience and not losing necessary, in-depth information. While this is certainly challenging, she also found the process very interesting.

Get Involved!

Swaan and Luuk are encouraged that All for Hungary already has tens of thousands of views on YouTube; they hope that the documentary helps to open up the debate about why Hungary’s educated youth are so attracted to the far right Jobbik party. Swaan regularly writes about related topics, and she has organized screenings of the documentary along with follow-up discussions by those who attend. She is always willing to come and show the documentary at a lecture, conference or any other occasion! If you would like to discuss the issue, use the film as part of your own event or project or discuss ideas for other documentaries, you can get in touch with Swaan by sending her a message through her Humanity in Action Senior Fellow profile.

Funding

Thanks to the financial support of Humanity in Action and Folia Magazine, Swaan and Luuk were able to cover their flights and their stay in Hungary.

Share this Project

About This Project

HIA Program:

Netherlands Netherlands 2010

Developed by:

Related Media

Night without a Roof
by Petra Rietberg, Netherlands 2010
Changing Identity in Europe
by Frans Timmermans, Netherlands 2010
Bringing Down a Dictator
by Srdja Popovic, Netherlands 2010
Why Should My Conscience Bother Me?
by Loran Nordgren, Netherlands 2010
Successful Strategies for Nonviolent Civil Resistance
by Srdja Popovic, Netherlands 2010
Citizen Journalism in Unlikely Places
by Mark Fonseca Rendeiro, Netherlands 2010
Browse all content